So we thought we’d start blog post with a quick and topical quiz for you!
Thinking about the recent Liberal Party’s behaviour that led to the deposing of Malcolm Turnbull as Australia’s Prime Minister, were you:
(d) none of the above.
Regardless of your response, you may in any event have found yourself quoting the political commentator and author, Mark Twain: “Truth is stranger than fiction”. At Worklogic, we have been finding solace in quoting a more contemporary but timeless phrase, and song: “Mamma Mia, here we go again”.
At the same time, however, our intellectual curiosity was certainly also piqued by the recent Canberra shenanigans. In particular, we were very keen to identify how many of the twelve core workplace team dysfunctions, which we have set out in our recently published book, “Fix Your Team”, were at play last week.
The answer? In summary, we have identified a perfect storm of no less than nine dysfunctional workplace team pathologies at play!
The 9 dysfunctions of the Federal Liberal team
1. Gossip Culture
Cliques, rumour, innuendo abounded in Canberra last week. Left unchecked, this type of destructive communication will inevitably lead to a serious lack of trust in any workplace. Certainly, two majorly factional cliques within the Liberal Party, together with the apparent existence of a ‘dirt file’ at the ready for use against a sitting PM, was never going to help with focusing everyone’s attention on the core business of leading the country. In fact, it led to parliament closing down early for the day, the first such occasion since Federation. Ouch.
2. Toxic Personalities
Well, dare we note that a lot of politicians do have big personalities. Confidence will certainly help you put yourself forward as a candidate in the first place, and also to survive in the complex field of politics. But when individuals are acting in sarcastic, negative and disrespectful ways towards each other, the result is that communication dries up, and mistrust kicks in. Who needs an opposition to throw barbed criticism in parliament, when members within your own team are undermining you from within the team?
3. Bad behaviour going unchecked
Any organisation needs to be able to say; “That is not appropriate behaviour”. When no-one is holding anyone to account, tricky behaviour can and does become normalised.
4. Skeleton in the closet
The deposing of Tony Abbott by Malcolm Turnbull clearly created a massive ‘skeleton in the closet’. Tony Abbott continued to seethe from the backbench and most political commentators this week have acknowledged that vengeance was the key driver behind the leadership spill.
Clearly the change in team leader from Tony Abbott to Malcolm Turnbull was not properly discussed, resolved, and, any resentment and anger identified and “put to bed”. How Malcolm Turnbull became leader was ’unfinished business’ – for some. It prevented the team from focussing on its core business, and came back to really destroy team unity.
5. Lack of diversity
The broader the demographic in a team, the more likely you are to have innovative and creative ways of thinking. So, how demographically varied are the MPSs of the Liberal Party Room? At a glance: mainly male, mainly white, mainly straight, mainly middle-aged – with the emphasis on mainly. Maybe, just maybe, a bit more diversity might have influenced how the group acted and behaved in recent weeks.
6. Manager’s style
“It’s not them (the team), it’s you”, to quote Chapter 9 of Fix Your Team.
Whilst Malcolm Turnbull was labelling last week an “insurgency”, he would do well to reflect on whether his own behaviour was inadvertently a factor which contributed to the leadership crises last week.
Reneging on policies or promises in order to appease certain team members in a bid “to be liked at all costs” may have short term gains, but can backfire in the longer term. It may lead to a sense that anything (and everything) can be successfully challenged in time. If a leader indicates a sense that he is unable to effectively lead his team with a clear and consistent vision, then one needs to query if he is actually a leader in all but name.
7. Organised chaos
“Who is doing what? Who is saying what? What are we here to do?”
There was not much sense of a plan last week, or if there was, it soon seemed to turn into daily organised chaos, with no-one really getting what they wanted or knowing in fact what they wanted.
Too much workload can lead to exhaustion, stress, and a lack of clear thinking in decision making. Just saying.
9. Unhealthy competition
When a team is not unified, and not aiming to achieve the same things, and personal glory, power and status are seen as the ultimate prize, rather than the team’s goals, then team members act out of obsessive self-interest. That situation never ends well.
The 3 missing team dysfunctions
And so, what, we hear you ask, were the three core dysfunctions that were not present last week?
10. Nepotism: No one was trying to get their nephew to be pope or PM.
11. Workplace romance gone wrong: It was never “a love-in” that went sour.
12. Personal crisis: The crisis was all about the team. As far as we know, no-one’s behaviour was affected by domestic issues or crises.
6 fixes to address this team’s dysfunction
It is not uncommon for teams that need to be fixed to exhibit a few dysfunctions at the same time. Nine dysfunctions, however, is certainly a disturbingly high number. We strongly suggest that, to resolve the above, the Federal Liberal Party put our “Fix Your Team” philosophy into action, by implementing these six fixes:
- Address unhealthy conflict
- Address unconstructive individual behaviour
- Develop the team’s character and connections
- Align with values
- Develop leadership and management
- Care for each other
We look forward to Worklogic having a confidential chat with ScoMo re the above!